the top watch looks way to busy... when you're lost in the wods and being chased by a bear do you really wanna have to take a whole minute to stop and try to find the time.
but in all seriousness, too busy. but let me ask you a question.... when you're in the woods all summer and pretty much alone, why does the shine of the watch matter? i could see it mattering if you were looking for a party/date watch...but why does it matter in the woods? I would go for something thats functional and easy to use. just MO