In all fairness I only give 1's to non BMW's - this is after all a BMW forum.
But really I just sat there and clicked through giving a score quickly to what my first impressions were at the exact time I laid eyes on each pic, unfortunately that means most stock cars got low scores as they are no different to any other (unless they were a rarer model in great nick - like a 2002 or something or just a model which gets my juices going - 8 series, M5 and the like), nearly stock didn't fair much higher, but cars that have been tastefully modified and were instantly pleasing to the eye received a good rating.
Sorry if that pisses people off but if I don't like stock e36's I ain't gonna score it high, but if someone spends a good few grand making their e36 look better than the original then surely they should receive a better score. Would anyone rate my bog standard 523 up there with an e60 m5??? I don't think so and wouldn't expect anyone too, should this change if I spend a few quid a a set of riims??? Only if they make a big impact in the way the car looks I would have thought or you are just mad on the e39's in general.