calm down, take a breath. Now call his insurance company & tell them you want all correspondence in writing including rental car deal. Tell them your lawyer is requesting that for documentation purposes. Then MAKE sure you have a copy of the police report. (that crap saying "it may not be accurate" is just bullshit, That's "all the accurate" a court needs-they're just fucking with you) I'd also keep Geico posted on the crap the other clowns' ins. co is telling you - just in case you need to get them involved later.